SoDeep IconSoDeep
·
The public fallout between Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung

The public fallout between Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung

@ChaiWithChitra · June 16, 2026

Imagine the messiest breakup in history, but instead of fighting over a cat, these two titans fought over the human soul. Sigmund Freud hand-picked Carl Jung as his "Prince Regent," but their bromance died because Freud insisted every human quirk was just a repressed sexual urge.

Jung disagreed, arguing we actually share a "collective unconscious"—a giant, ancient hard drive of myths we’re all born with. Freud took this pivot personally, viewing it as a mystical betrayal. They stopped speaking entirely, turning a simple disagreement into a lifelong cold war that permanently fractured psychology.

Wait, how does an 'ancient hard drive' of myths even get inside our heads?

Think of it as evolutionary "bloatware." Jung argued that just as we inherit a physical heart or lungs, we inherit a mental structure shaped by thousands of years of human experience.

You don't need to be taught what a "Mother" figure or a "Monster" is. These archetypes are universal patterns burned into our DNA, like a shared cloud storage that every human baby automatically syncs with the moment they're born.

If it’s all pre-installed, can we ever actually delete this "bloatware"?

Short answer: No. You can’t uninstall your own operating system. These archetypes are the foundation of how you perceive reality; trying to delete them would be like a computer trying to delete its own motherboard.

But here’s the twist—while you can't hit "delete," you can stop being a mindless user. Jung called this "individuation." It’s basically the process of realizing which "apps" are running in the background so they stop making decisions for you without your permission.

What’s the giveaway that an archetype has taken over my brain?

Look for the over-reaction. If you’ve ever met a stranger and felt a sudden, irrational urge to roast them for no reason, congratulations—you’ve been hijacked.

Jung called this projection. Your brain takes a part of yourself you secretly despise—your Shadow—and pastes it onto someone else like a messy Photoshop job.

When you're possessed by an archetype, you lose your nuance. You stop being a complex person and start acting like a predictable trope in a very old, very dramatic play.

So what kind of stuff is actually lurking in this 'Shadow' closet?

Think of your Shadow as your personality’s 'reject pile.' Since you were a kid, you’ve been shoving 'unacceptable' traits—like anger, greed, or even raw ambition—into a dark basement just to stay likable.

It’s not just 'evil' stuff. If you were taught that being emotional is weak, your sensitivity is down there too. It’s a collection of every part of yourself you’ve labeled 'not me.'

These traits don't disappear. They sit in the dark, getting louder, until they eventually burst out and hijack your behavior when you're caught off guard.

Explore in card mode →

Related topics

The 1518 'Dancing Plague' that gripped the streets of StrasbourgThe lifelong political feud between the Mitford sistersThe elaborate hoax of Princess Caraboo in British societyThe Petticoat Affair in Andrew Jackson's cabinetThe strategic etiquette used to control nobles at VersaillesThe scandalous auction of the Roman Empire to Didius Julianus